Q/A: Two Payers Both Paid the Claim. Who Gets the Refund?

May 13th, 2019 - Wyn Staheli, Director of Research
Categories:   Billing   Compliance   Practice Management  
0 Votes - Sign in to vote or comment.

Question 

We have a personal injury situation where we submitted a claim was sent to the patient's auto policy carrier who refused payment. We then submitted it to her other insurance. Eventually, both companies paid her claims. Her auto paid at full value, and her secondary paid at a reduced rate due to my contract agreement with them. Her account now has a credit balance. What do I do with the overpayment? Do I keep it? Is there a formula for parsing it to refund to the insurance carriers?

Answer

First and foremost, you can NOT keep the money. As for who gets the refund, it is essential to determine which policy is the primary policy and what type of secondary policy the patient has. In most cases, you would refund the money to the secondary payer. For example, if the auto policy was primary, keep their payment and then refund the secondary payer for the amount that they paid. Be sure to include a letter along with the refund to explain what happened.

However, be alert to rare occasions when the overpayment could belong to the patient (who paid the secondary premiums without any coordination of benefits). Legally, it all depends upon the terms in the contract. You don't want to send the money to the secondary payer when in fact it should have been sent to the patient.

To avoid this potential problem, we suggest a letter to the secondary payer with a copy to the patient stating: “Both primary and secondary policies have paid and there is now an overpayment, and we assume that it could belong to the patient. If we do not hear from you by (e.g., June 30th, 20__) we will remit the overpayment to the patient.”

The bottom line: Avoid any perception of duplicate billing, misrepresentation or fraud, and at the same do not overlook any amounts due to the patient.

###

Questions, comments?

If you have questions or comments about this article please contact us.  Comments that provide additional related information may be added here by our Editors.


Latest articles:  (any category)

RT and LT Modifier Usage Change (effective 2019-03-01)
May 21st, 2019 - Chris Woolstenhulme, QCC, CMCS, CPC, CMRS
According to Noridian Medicare, there are new changes required when reporting the RT and LT modifier(s). In the past, it was appropriate to bill the RT and LT modifier on the same line when it was required for certain HCPCS codes. Noridian released a publication stating claims reported with RT/LT on the same ...
Do You Understand Medicare
May 21st, 2019 - Christine Taxin
Even though we may think we truly understand what it means to be a participating provider, Medicare doesn’t quite work the way that other insurance plans do. Far too many providers do not understand the difference and get into hot water. To further complicate matters, the rules are different for ...
An Update on the DHS OIG's Effort to Combat Fraud & Abuse
May 17th, 2019 - Namas
An Update on the DHS OIG's Effort to Combat Fraud & Abuse Every year, the Department of Health and Human Services (DHS) Office of Inspector General (OIG) is required by law to release a report detailing the amounts deposited and appropriated to the Medicare Trust Fund, and the source of such ...
Prioritize Your Patient's Financial Experience
May 13th, 2019 - Wyn Staheli, Director of Research
For many years, the ChiroCode DeskBook has emphasized the need for providers to firmly establish the patient’s financial responsibility through clear communication. We even created a “Patient Financial Responsibility Acknowledgment Form” to help providers with this process. Lately, the lack of pricing transparency has been in the news and even ...
Q/A: Two Payers Both Paid the Claim. Who Gets the Refund?
May 13th, 2019 - Wyn Staheli, Director of Research
Question We have a personal injury situation where we submitted a claim was sent to the patient's auto policy carrier who refused payment. We then submitted it to her other insurance. Eventually, both companies paid her claims. Her auto paid at full value, and her secondary paid at a reduced rate ...
HIPAA Violation Penalties Revised
May 6th, 2019 - Wyn Staheli, Director of Research
On April 30, 2019 The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) announced that “HHS will apply a different cumulative annual CMP limit for each of the four penalties tiers in the HITECH Act.” Unlike other notices which require a proposed rule with a comment period, this notice will take ...
Q/A: If Orthopedic Tests are Negative, do You List Them in Your Treatment Notes?
May 6th, 2019 - Wyn Staheli, Director of Research
Question: If orthopedic tests are negative, do you need to still list them in your treatment notes? Answer: Yes. Any tests which are performed by a healthcare provider, regardless of the result, should be documented in the patient record. This record is the only way that a reviewer or another provider ...



About Codapedia & Find-A-Code Contact Us Terms of Use Privacy Policy Advertise with Us

Codapedia™/Find-A-Code™ - 62 E 300 North, Spanish Fork, UT 84660 - Phone 801-770-4203 (9-5 Mountain) - Fax (801) 770-4428

Copyright © 2009-2019 Find A Code, LLC - CPT® copyright American Medical Association